"It is definitely a game between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Reds. It is either on May 1 or May 2, 1959. I believe it was from May 2 because of several reasons. First of all, WLW 7 is from May 2. Also May 2 was on a Saturday. A lot of teams played day games on Saturday during that era. Also once again, the scoreboard shows Baltimore playing at Kansas City. The Reds and Dodgers only played twice when the Orioles and Athletics were playing and it was on May 1 and May 2. 1959. The scoreboard is very difficult to read from this picture but the pitcher is definitely left handed. At the top left hand corner of the scoreboard, the pitchers number appears to begin with a "3" and the second digit looks to be a one or seven. However if you look in the lineup you can actually make out the "7" as being the second number. The Dodgers' lefthander appears to be Gene Snyder who only had two starts in his major league career. He also pitched only 26.1 innings in his career and finished with a hefty 5.47 ERA. If it is the May 2 game, WLW 7 reveals that the Reds scored two runs in the third inning and seven runs in the fourth which could have significantly ballooned his ERA. It is somewhat ironic because he was traded by the Phillies to the Dodgers along with Jim Golden and Rip Repulski for a journeyman player named George "Sparky" Anderson!!! The hitter in the picture appears to be Vada Pinson. There are several pieces of evidence to support that. Frankly it looks very much like his follow through on his swing. Also Frank Robinson (20) is in the on deck circle. According to the scoreboard there is only one out in the bottom of the first inning and Pinson usually batted third. Perhaps he was batting second in this game or maybe Snyder had walked a batter. Also if you look at the scoreboard, it appears that the number of the batter at the plate began with a "2". The second number looks similar to an "8" although it could be another number. The only Reds' starter that batted left handed that year with a uniform number that began with "2" was Gus Bell. There were some bench players with numbers that began with a "2" and it is feasible that it could be one of them. "
And the following information has been provided by Brad Coffman:
"I was looking at the WLW photos. #s 6 & 9 were taken at a game on May 2, 1959 in a game against LA. Ron Martin has done a very good job of supplying info about those photos. I'm sure the player in #9 is Robinson playing LF. Snider was lefthanded and Pinson would have been in right-center with Robby pulled over to the right by the scoreboard. The scorecard from the game at Baseball Almanac has Robby in LF and Pinson in CF.
Of note are the facts that the Reds won 16-4 and Robinson became the 6th Red to hit for the cycle and the first to hit for a "natural cycle". In 1989 Eric Davis became the 7th and his was also natural.
In photo #6 the batter is Pinson as Mr Martin suspects. He did hit 2nd that day with Robbie hitting 3rd."
|
